I'll start by saying the wait was well worth it. It's too early to say this is my all-time favorite pedal, but I will say I have never enjoyed a pedal so much in the first week I've had it, except possibly the Supa Quack....it's neck and neck. It is the perfect distortion for me and where I'm at right now. Anyway, here goes....
I. Gear used Guitar --- 1998 Thinline Fender Tele (USA made) with Fralin blues and a Torres 5 way switch
Amp --- Germino Club 40 with Celestion Greenbacks (G12h's)
I love the way this combo sounds so much I have not touched my Victoria or my Strat in days!!!
II. Circumstances My neighbor was gone for the first 2 days I had it so it was band setting loud and since then it's just at moderate/reasonable levels.
III. General thoughts For the first chord, the Cliffhanger gave me a grin a mile wide. It is SICK! It is literally AC/DC and Guns 'N Roses right out of the box. As I was playing it, I thought, "this is what a distortion is supposed to sound like".
IV. Evaluation of functionality & Comparison to other distortions Just two knobs on this bad boy....Volume and Distortion. It is pure Marshall venom and the only choice is how much you want. As expected, the full range of each dial is useable. I cranked the Vol and Distortion and it sounded phenominal....no hiss, no feedback, no craziness. In addition, it retained it's character...it was still tight and edgy. No matter where the distortion level is, it sounds great. Using the combination of volume, distortion and the guitar's volume knob, there is a pretty good range of distortion, but the range is not what I'd call "versatile". In other words, if you've got the Cliffhanger on, I'd expect you are rocking out. I think it would be fair to call this a one trick pony, but the one trick is just amazingly good. This was by design I'm guessing. To give the pedal more versatility would defeat the purpose it was created for I think.
In the BJF family of distortion, the Cliffhanger is the meanest. It has an edgy quality like no other BJF distortion possesses. It is most similar to the Dyna Red in my opinion....it is kind of like a custom shop version of the Dyna Red, which has been specially voiced "FOR THOSE ABOUT TO ROCK."
V Stacking So far I haven't had much desire to stack the Cliffhanger. It sounds great by itself and doesn't feel like it is lacking anything. I did try it with the PGC and as you would expect, the PGC adds the magic touch and makes it sound that much better. I've also ran it with my Supa Quack and they get along great. My next experiment will be to try to SBEQ with it.
VII What situations / kind of music can you see using the pedal for? Straight ahead, earth shaking rock 'n roll. It is a timeless distortion that neither feels old or modern, it is just what rock sounds like (or should sound like).
VII Suggested improvements The only thing I would say is that at times I wished I could roll off some of the treble. That said, I rediscovered the tone knob on my tele and all is well!
If anything, I might suggest adding an internal "set it and forget it trimmer" to adjust treble according to your rig, but in all honesty, that's not necessary as long as your guitar has a tone knob. I wouldn't do anything that might alter the character of the distortion here.
VII I Bottom line --- is it a keeper? What does it knock off your board?It may be my favorite BJF pedal of all-time. We'll see once the honeymoon is over, but so far, it is a KILLER and then some. It occupies it's own niche, so I'm not ready to say it replaces the Dyna Red or anything like that (Dyna is much more versatile and different in character). I'd say the pedal that stands the greatest risk of being banished to the emporium is the Fetto Deluxe....a great pedal in it's own right, but the Cliffhanger is something else.
Lastly, I would say, full speed ahead on this one Bjorn. This one could be the next BJF legend!