That said, I did get a chance to try the SOOD myself. Unfortunately, I didn't get a chance to gig with it ... so I can't comment on how it fares in a live mix as compared to the SYOD (of which I have the Amber prototype).
I agree with much of what's been said here, that the SOOD is likely a more versatile "stand alone" OD that many would prefer if they could only pick one.
However, the SYOD has a uniqueness to its voicing that is very different from any other OD I've tried. In a band mix, it is indeed most impressive as it cuts through in a most pleasing way like none other.
I personally wouldn't make the change either. I really like the way my OD cuts through the band mix. I really do think the SOOD is an excellent pedal, and I'd likely by one if I didn't already have my SYOD/Amber. If I could choose, though, I'd pick the original Yellow circuit.
Cheers,
Doc
