sonictroubadour wrote:I think whichever way you choose to go will be fine (though, for the record, I voted for matching color with the top), but if it were me, I would definitely do them all only one way. Sure, options are nice for the customers, but, in a variety of ways (keeping track of who gets what, that you've got the right number of each variety, etc.), producing multiple varieties could end up being a huge hassle for you! Keep it simple for your own benefit as a manufacturer/distributor!
I agree about choosing one way and sticking to it -- options will just bog you down. The main reason I vote for powder coated to match the text is just to provide a more durable finish to velcro to. I WANT to velcro the bottom plates of my pedals and don't want the velcro/back paint left sitting on my board when I decide to switch things around. I guess I'm coming from a slightly different place of wanting the powder coated backplate for utility purposes and collectability be damned. If the top chips I'm OK with that but if I have to keep reapplying velcro until I get to bare metal, that I find frustrating.
Currently I do use replacement back plates or the diaper method on my BJFe pedals (with the exception of the old beat up DRD) but I think since the BF line is aimed more toward the budget/gigging musician (I think) they should have more durable back plates.