Great post, Cabo!
I am in two bands right now, one cover band and one originals band. The cover band is great fun and manages to have a steady gig schedule. The originals band is more of an artistic thing for me in that I don't really make any money doing it, and we gig way less often ... as that just seems to be the way things go with original bands yet undiscovered.
The cover band is a six-piece, featuring drums, bass, two guitars, and both a male and a female lead singer. The other guitarist also plays keyboards on some tunes. I find that any time there is a second midrange instrument (like another guitar), it is especially important to find the right tools that will allow both players to be heard. We play a variety of "bar band" music, basically rock tunes from the 60s thru present...with a few "newer" country tunes thrown in there as well. I need a reasonably versatile sonic palette from which to draw, but not too over-the-top. I have five BJF pedals, a wah, and a volume pedal. Each of these pedals is a unique and indispensable part of my live rig.
The originals band is a four-piece, featuring drums, bass, guitar, and keyboards (also the vocalist). In this mix, it is often easier for my guitar to cut through just because it's the only guitar. But balancing sounds with a full-range instrument such as keyboards can also present its own challenges in a live setting. I use the very same set-up in this band as with the cover band, but will use different pedals for slightly different applications. The material in this band would best be described as melodic progressive rock. Very big, very loud, with "guitar hero" solos, etc.
I have two electric guitars. The main one is a David Thomas McNaught Vintage Singlecut (like a Les Paul), with a pair of Rio Grande Texas BBQ humbuckers. The other guitar is a Korean Strat that I upgraded with G&L Magnetic Field Design single coil strat pickups (taken out of an S-500).
Amp is a Guytron GT100 head, into a Port City Wave 2x12 cabinet, loaded with a Celestion Classic Lead 80 and an Avatar Hellatone 60 (which is basically a broken in Vintage 30).
The cleanest sound I ever use still has some hair on it. I don't use any squeaky-clean SF Twin sounds at all. If I need it to be really clean, I will back down the volume on my guitar a notch. Overall, this set-up yields just enough dirt from the amp (not too much, though, it's still "clean enough" for rock-n-roll) for me to blend the sounds of my BJF pedals with it.
Great stuff!!!
Doc